Personal injury intake software RFP template
Turn a software search into one comparable, evidence-based buying process. Define PI intake requirements, issue the same questions, run four fictional-data demonstrations, score supported evidence, and preserve the final decision and conditions.
Compare proof, not presentation quality
Give shortlisted vendors the same scope, definitions, fictional scenarios, evidence requests, and pricing period. Record whether a capability is delivered, configured, partner-provided, custom, planned, or unavailable. A polished demo is not evidence that a proposed workflow, contract, export, or failure path works.
Procurement sequence
Use this RFP in four controlled stages
The workbook is deliberately reusable: a small firm can use it as a structured request and scorecard, while a larger firm can incorporate it into its formal procurement, security, legal, and implementation process.
Define the operating boundary
Name the intake channels, users, matter types, current systems, data, decisions, and handoffs that the proposed product may touch.
Issue one comparable question set
Give every vendor the same requirements, evidence requests, pricing period, assumptions, and response format before the demonstration.
Run the same fictional proof tests
Use invented people, facts, files, conflict parties, and contact details to test ordinary work, corrections, failure paths, and export.
Record the decision and conditions
Score only supported evidence, document exceptions and unresolved questions, and assign owners before contract or implementation approval.
Response language
Label requirements before vendors answer
Assign priority and acceptable evidence in advance. Do not turn every preference into a mandatory requirement, and do not award full credit to a feature that is only promised on a roadmap.
| Label | How to use it |
|---|---|
| Must | A documented condition of selection. Define how the vendor must prove it and what happens if the requirement is not met. |
| Should | A valuable capability that can affect scoring but is not an automatic disqualifier. State the acceptable evidence. |
| Future | A possible later need. Ask whether it exists today, is contracted, or is merely planned; do not score a roadmap promise as delivered. |
| Out of scope | A task or decision the product will not perform. Use this to prevent assumption drift during demonstrations and contracting. |
Firm brief
Record the current state before writing requirements
Complete this brief once and send the same version to every vendor. Use the firm's own ranges and definitions; this template supplies no universal volume, response-time, staffing, or conversion benchmark.
- 01.Practice areas, jurisdictions, offices, languages, and accessibility needs: ____________________
- 02.Current monthly inquiry range, seasonality, channels, lead sources, and after-hours coverage: ____________________
- 03.Intake, attorney, operations, IT, security, finance, and executive decision owners: ____________________
- 04.Current intake, phone, email, calendar, document, e-signature, advertising, and case systems: ____________________
- 05.Existing stages for new, pending, conflict review, consultation, accepted, declined, referred, and handed-off work: ____________________
- 06.Data, files, history, users, integrations, and reporting that must be migrated or preserved: ____________________
- 07.Known workflow failures, manual work, duplicate entry, reporting gaps, and control concerns: ____________________
- 08.Required selection, contracting, configuration, test, training, migration, and launch windows: ____________________
Vendor response instructions
Require one dated answer format from every vendor
Each response should name the quoted edition, dependencies, setup and recurring cost, current evidence, responsible provider, limitations, and answer date. Separate native product behavior from partner work, custom services, manual steps, and roadmap plans.
Standard today
Included in the quoted edition now. Name the current product, plan, documentation, and proof environment.
Configurable
Available through supported configuration. State who configures it, the effort, limits, and ongoing owner.
Partner or custom
Requires another provider, integration, or professional services. Identify the dependency, cost, support path, and contract.
Roadmap
Not delivered in the evaluated product. Date the statement, but do not score it as a current capability.
Unavailable
Cannot meet the requirement in the proposed solution. Record any manual workaround and its owner without converting it into product support.
Copy-ready requirements
Nine-part PI intake software RFP
For every line, add a priority, response, evidence requirement, owner, and result. Remove irrelevant questions and add firm-specific rules, jurisdictions, client requirements, data types, integrations, and contract terms before issuing the document.
Procurement scope and system boundary
Make the proposed system, users, records, locations, environments, and excluded work explicit before comparing features.
- RFP-01.1Identify the proposed products, editions, add-ons, implementation services, support tiers, and third-party services in scope.
- RFP-01.2Map which system owns inquiry, contact, conflict, consultation, engagement, decline, referral, and retained-matter records at each stage.
- RFP-01.3List the staff, attorneys, contractors, administrators, external users, and integrations that require access, including role boundaries.
- RFP-01.4State which legal, medical, conflicts, deadline, valuation, and representation decisions remain outside the product.
Evidence to request
Proposed architecture, license and service schedule, responsibility map, role list, and written exclusions tied to the quoted configuration.
Intake channels, response, and ownership
Test whether every inquiry becomes an owned, visible record without implying that an acknowledgement creates representation.
- RFP-02.1Describe supported web, phone, email, referral, chat, advertising, manual-entry, and import paths, including duplicate handling.
- RFP-02.2Show how the firm assigns an owner, target, next action, escalation, and backup owner for new and reopened inquiries.
- RFP-02.3Explain acknowledgement, scheduling, consent, language, accessibility, failed delivery, opt-out, and safe-contact controls.
- RFP-02.4Show how supervisors find unassigned, stale, failed, paused, duplicate, or exception records without relying on a shared inbox.
Evidence to request
Channel inventory, workflow diagram, notification and escalation rules, failure queue, sample activity history, and configuration demonstration.
PI data model and staged information collection
Confirm that the firm can collect only the information appropriate to the current stage and preserve the source of material facts.
- RFP-03.1Support configurable fields for incident, parties, injuries, treatment, insurance, employment, witnesses, documents, referral, and contact preferences.
- RFP-03.2Separate opening details from deeper qualification so the firm can control when sensitive or conflict-relevant information is requested.
- RFP-03.3Preserve who supplied or changed a material fact, when it changed, and the original source record or attachment.
- RFP-03.4Document validation, correction, incomplete-response, duplicate, and conflicting-information behavior for forms and imports.
Evidence to request
Field dictionary, stage map, sample source history, validation rules, change history, export sample, and a correction demonstration.
Conflicts, urgency, and attorney-controlled decisions
Require the product to support the firm’s approved process without turning a software result into legal analysis or a representation decision.
- RFP-04.1Show how conflict names and relationships are captured, normalized, searched, reviewed, restricted, and linked to the inquiry.
- RFP-04.2Show how dates or phrases that may need urgent review are surfaced to a named person without representing the alert as a legal deadline.
- RFP-04.3Restrict case qualification, legal or medical assessment, advice, acceptance, decline, referral, and engagement actions to authorized workflows.
- RFP-04.4Preserve reviewer identity, decision, reason, conditions, supporting record, and any required second review or escalation.
Evidence to request
Conflict workflow, alert and escalation sample, permission matrix, decision history, override controls, and exception-path demonstration.
Workflow, communications, documents, and handoff
Verify that the proposed workflow keeps the authoritative record, communications, tasks, files, and retained-matter handoff reconcilable.
- RFP-05.1Demonstrate configurable stages, tasks, notes, consultations, reminders, templates, approvals, and escalation without silent status changes.
- RFP-05.2Keep outbound email, SMS, portal, and document activity attributable, reviewable, and linked to the correct inquiry or matter.
- RFP-05.3Describe file upload, download, scanning, version, access, signature, retention, and wrong-record correction behavior.
- RFP-05.4Show the accepted-matter handoff, rejected or referred disposition, source-to-target reconciliation, retry behavior, and failure ownership.
Evidence to request
Workflow configuration, activity history, communication and file samples, approval record, handoff map, reconciliation report, and failed-delivery queue.
Integrations, data authority, reporting, and portability
Test current integrations and exit paths as operating controls rather than treating a logo or roadmap entry as proof.
- RFP-06.1List each native, partner, API, webhook, file, calendar, advertising, telephony, e-signature, and case-management connection in the proposal.
- RFP-06.2For every connection, identify direction, fields, source of truth, timing, authentication, permissions, retries, duplicates, reconciliation, and support owner.
- RFP-06.3Provide role-filtered operational reporting for intake source, owner, stage, response, consultation, decision, handoff, exceptions, and data quality.
- RFP-06.4Provide a usable export of configured fields, relationships, notes, activities, communications, files, and identifiers, with documented limits.
Evidence to request
Integration specification, API or file documentation, error and retry sample, reconciliation evidence, report samples, and representative export package.
Security, privacy, AI, retention, and incident evidence
Ask for evidence matched to the actual service, data, users, subprocessors, and contract rather than relying on a generic security claim.
- RFP-07.1Document identity, MFA, role and tenant separation, privileged access, support access, encryption, logging, monitoring, vulnerability, and change controls.
- RFP-07.2Map data locations, subprocessors, cross-service flows, backups, retention, deletion, legal hold, recovery, and end-of-service handling.
- RFP-07.3For each AI-assisted feature, disclose the purpose, inputs, providers, retention, training or improvement use, reviewer, source visibility, correction, and disable controls.
- RFP-07.4Describe security-event notification, investigation, evidence preservation, service restoration, customer responsibilities, and current assurance scope.
Evidence to request
Current data-flow and subprocessor records, security documentation, assurance artifacts, access and log samples, AI feature inventory, retention schedule, and incident terms.
Implementation, migration, training, and continuity
Define a reversible rollout with named owners, acceptance evidence, support routes, and an agreed response to failed migration or go-live criteria.
- RFP-08.1Provide discovery, configuration, mapping, test, training, acceptance, launch, stabilization, and change-control activities with owners and assumptions.
- RFP-08.2Define migration scope, exclusions, field and relationship mapping, attachment handling, duplicates, validation, exception repair, reconciliation, and sign-off.
- RFP-08.3Provide role-based training and administrator handoff using the configured workflow, not only a generic product tour.
- RFP-08.4Define source-system freeze or coexistence, rollback, outage, vendor delay, staff absence, critical defect, and post-launch support paths.
Evidence to request
Project plan, responsibility matrix, migration workbook, test-import report, acceptance criteria, training plan, continuity plan, escalation route, and sample change order.
Pricing, support, contract change, renewal, and exit
Make every cost driver and operating dependency visible over the same comparison period and through the end of the relationship.
- RFP-09.1Quote subscription, users, volume, communications, storage, AI, integrations, implementation, migration, training, support, taxes, and optional services separately.
- RFP-09.2State billing units, included allowances, overage, minimums, proration, credits, price changes, renewal, cancellation, refund, suspension, and failed-payment terms.
- RFP-09.3Define support channels, hours, severity, response and restoration targets, escalation, professional services, and excluded support work.
- RFP-09.4Define export assistance, deletion confirmation, transition access, fees, timing, vendor dependencies, and obligations that survive termination.
Evidence to request
Completed 12-month cost worksheet, order form, service and support terms, usage definitions, change and renewal terms, export sample, and exit schedule.
Fictional-data proof test
Make every vendor run the same four scenarios
Use a test environment and invented people, facts, contact details, conflict names, documents, and matters. Do not place client or prospective-client information into a sales demonstration. Ask the vendor to show the full record, permissions, history, failure queue, correction, export, and follow-up evidence—not only the happy path.
New inquiry with missing and conflicting facts
Setup
Create a fictional vehicle-collision inquiry from a web form. Omit a treatment answer, enter two different incident dates in separate source records, and use a shared family email address.
Require the vendor to prove
Source preservation, missing-field handling, contradiction visibility, safe acknowledgement, owner assignment, next action, correction history, and no unsupported case decision.
Duplicate contact and conflict-review exception
Setup
Submit a fictional referral whose phone number matches an existing contact and whose adverse party resembles a name already in the test conflict set.
Require the vendor to prove
Duplicate suggestions without destructive merging, staged information collection, restricted conflict details, named review, pause and resume behavior, and attributable disposition.
After-hours follow-up with a failed delivery
Setup
Create a fictional after-hours inquiry with a requested callback window. Cause the first outbound channel to fail, then change the contact preference and revoke one communication permission.
Require the vendor to prove
Visible failure, escalation, preference and consent history, neutral message content, backup ownership, reviewed follow-up, and no silent completion.
Accepted-matter handoff, correction, export, and exit
Setup
Move a fictional approved inquiry through a test handoff. Correct one source field after the first transfer, retry a failed attachment, export the record, remove a user, and request deletion of the test workspace.
Require the vendor to prove
Authority mapping, idempotent retry, reconciliation, source-linked correction, permissions removal, usable export, retention explanation, and deletion evidence.
Comparable evidence
Keep one evidence ledger across every response
Capture what the vendor proved and the exact proposal assumptions. A link to a marketing page, an unsupported “yes,” or a future roadmap date should not be treated as equivalent to current product evidence and a matching contract term.
| Ledger field | What to record |
|---|---|
| Requirement ID | Stable reference such as RFP-04.2 |
| Priority | Must, Should, Future, or Out of scope |
| Vendor response | Delivered, configured, partner, custom, roadmap, or unavailable |
| Evidence | Document, contract term, live proof, export, log, report, or test result |
| Assumption or limit | Edition, add-on, volume, role, region, dependency, or exclusion |
| Owner | Person responsible for verification and follow-up |
| Result | Supported, partially supported, unsupported, or unresolved |
| Decision effect | Score, condition, exception, remediation, or disqualification |
Twelve-month cost worksheet
Normalize every proposal into the same cost period
Require each vendor to identify the billing unit, quantity, included allowance, one-time amount, recurring amount, assumption, and unresolved item for the same twelve-month scope. Keep taxes and optional work separate. For a deeper budgeting method, use the PI intake software pricing guide.
| Cost category | Unit / quantity / allowance | One-time | 12-month recurring | Assumption / unresolved item |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subscription, seats, minimums, and included usage | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Messaging, telephony, storage, AI, and other metered usage | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Implementation, configuration, project management, and testing | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Migration, cleanup, mapping, reconciliation, and rollback | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Integrations, partner services, custom work, and maintenance | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Role-based training, administrator handoff, and internal staff time | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Support tier, professional services, overages, and service credits | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Renewal change, taxes, export, transition, deletion, and exit assistance | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ | ____________ |
| Comparable first-year total | — | ____________ | ____________ | Taxes / unknowns: ____________ |
Vendor scorecard
Weight the decision before opening final responses
This template intentionally supplies no universal weights, passing score, or benchmark. The firm should define its priorities, scoring rules, mandatory conditions, disqualifiers, and decision authority before seeing vendor totals. Score only the supported evidence for the proposed edition and services.
| Evaluation area | Weight | Vendor A | Vendor B | Vendor C | Evidence / condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PI intake workflow and staged data fit | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Response ownership, communications, and exceptions | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Attorney-controlled review and decision boundaries | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Security, privacy, AI, retention, and incident evidence | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Integrations, reconciliation, reporting, and portability | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Implementation, migration, training, and continuity | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Support, change management, and vendor accountability | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Twelve-month cost, contract clarity, renewal, and exit | ___% | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ___ / 3 | ____________ |
| Total | 100% | ____ | ____ | ____ | Decision record below |
Decision record
Preserve the reason, conditions, owners, and exit path
A total score does not resolve an unsupported mandatory requirement, contract exception, migration risk, or unclear data path. Record the decision separately and require owners to close every condition before the relevant approval or launch gate.
Decision: Select / Conditional select / Extend review / Do not select
Selected proposal and version: ____________________
Evidence confidence: High / Medium / Low
Total first-year cost and assumptions: ____________________
Open operational, security, migration, and contract risks: ____________________
Mandatory conditions before signature: ____________________
Conditions before migration or go-live: ____________________
Accepted exceptions and approving owner: ____________________
Unresolved evidence and due date: ____________________
Implementation and rollback authority: ____________________
Export, transition, and deletion owner: ____________________
Decision makers and date: ____________________
Source notes
Primary sources behind the evaluation boundaries
These sources inform the questions; they do not create a universal RFP, interpret any jurisdiction’s law, determine professional duties, or certify a vendor. Firms should verify the current authorities and requirements that apply to their work.
ABA Model Rule 1.6 — Confidentiality of Information ↗
The ABA model rule includes a reasonable-efforts provision concerning inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure or access. Model rules are not a substitute for the rules and law governing a particular firm.
ABA Model Rule 1.18 — Duties to Prospective Client ↗
The ABA model rule addresses information learned from prospective clients. Firms should determine the rules and intake procedures that apply in their jurisdictions.
ABA Formal Opinion 477R — Securing protected client information ↗
The ABA opinion describes fact-dependent safeguards for protected communications. It is not a universal technology prescription, and firms should assess their own duties and circumstances.
NIST SP 1305 — Cybersecurity Supply Chain Risk Management ↗
NIST describes using Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 to define supplier requirements and improve technology-acquisition risk management. It is voluntary guidance, not a certification.
CISA Secure by Demand Guide ↗
CISA provides questions software customers can use before, during, and after procurement to examine a manufacturer’s approach to secure products.
Continue the buying process
Connect requirements to cost, AI, migration, and proof
PI intake software pricing guide
Normalize quotes into a 12-month budget with published pricing, assumptions, and exit costs.
Open resource →PI intake software implementation plan
Turn the selected proposal into an owned rollout with field mapping, acceptance tests, cutover, rollback, and sign-off.
Open resource →AI intake vendor evaluation
Deepen the AI section with task boundaries, data paths, human review, and a bounded pilot.
Open resource →PI intake automation guide
Map ownership, exceptions, attorney review, and retained-matter handoff before configuration.
Open resource →CRM vs. case management
Define which system should own intake, matters, communications, and handoff records.
Open resource →Integrations and migration
Review ClaimVela’s current source, handoff, migration, reconciliation, and export boundaries.
Open resource →ClaimVela security
Compare the RFP security questions with ClaimVela’s published controls, providers, and limitations.
Open resource →Lawmatics vs. Lead Docket
See how a focused comparison separates evidence, scope, price, migration, and unresolved claims.
Open resource →PI intake specialist training
Translate the selected workflow into role-based training, supervised practice, and quality review.
Open resource →Frequently asked questions
PI intake software RFP FAQ
What is a law-firm software RFP?
A law-firm software request for proposal is a written set of operating requirements, response instructions, evidence requests, pricing assumptions, and evaluation rules sent to prospective vendors. Its purpose is to make competing answers easier to compare; it does not replace the firm's legal, security, privacy, contracting, or procurement review.
Does a small PI firm need a formal RFP?
Not always. A smaller firm can use the same workbook as a structured request for information or demo checklist. The useful discipline is to give each vendor the same requirements, fictional scenarios, evidence requests, cost assumptions, and decision rules before choosing a product.
What requirements belong in a PI intake software RFP?
Cover inquiry capture, PI-specific fields and branching, conflict-data capture, attorney review, follow-up, scheduling, documents, handoff, integrations, migration, access, security, retention, reporting, implementation, support, pricing, contract terms, and exit. Each requirement should name the actor, trigger, expected result, failure path, reviewer, and evidence needed.
How should vendors be compared fairly?
Issue one question set, require a common response format, test the same fictional scenarios, record evidence in one ledger, separate non-negotiable gates from weighted scoring, and keep unresolved conditions visible. Do not score a roadmap promise as a capability demonstrated today.
What data should a firm use in software demos?
Use fictional names, contact details, facts, files, conflict parties, and matter records. Do not place real prospective-client or client information into a sales or test environment until the firm has approved the data path, access, contract, and controls for that use.
How should total cost be captured?
Ask every vendor to price the same twelve-month scope, including subscription, users, usage, implementation, migration, training, integrations, storage, messaging, support, overages, AI features, renewal terms, internal effort, export, and exit. Record taxes and unknown items separately rather than assuming they are included.
Should AI requirements be included?
Yes, when AI-assisted work is in scope. Define the exact task, data path, allowed inputs and outputs, human reviewer, override and failure path, evidence required, retention expectations, and product tier. Avoid accepting a broad AI label as proof of a specific capability or safeguard.
Does this template prove compliance?
No. This template is an evaluation aid, not a certification or universal standard. Firms must assess the professional rules, laws, contractual duties, client requirements, regulated-data obligations, and risk decisions that apply to their jurisdictions and work.